Ice Cream


~NOTE:  all Wells Hollow Creamery ice cream flavors may vary weekly depending on our supplier~

Step 1. Choose a cup or a cone
Step 2. Choose your size
Step 3. Choose hard or soft serve ice cream
Step 4. Choose your flavor(s)
Step 5. Choose your topping(s)
Step 6. Or try one of our specialty treats


NEW Premium Ice Cream Flavors from our “Sweet 16” collection

Our "Sweet 16" premium line of ice cream has 16% butter fat for a richer, creamery taste!  If the flavor is not displayed on the flavor board overhead, we apologize but are currently sold out. 



Premium vanilla blend with honey, pulsed walnuts and Baklava pastry

Banana Nut

Premium vanilla blend with real bananas, and chocolate chips

Cannoli Ricotta

Premium vanilla blend mixed with Cannoli cream and cheese, pulsed with plain and chocolate Cannoli shells, chocolate chips 

Cookie Monster

Premium vanilla blend colored blue with chocolate chip cookies and M&M’s

Rum Raisin

Premium vanilla blend mixed with Rum Raison base and Rum favoring


These flavors are generally available in our freezers at all times.  If the flavor is not displayed on the flavor board overhead, we apologize but are currently sold out.  We cannot guarantee to have your flavor, however, we strive to keep our 50+ flavor inventory consistent.


Amaretto Cherry

Amaretto cherry ice cream loaded with cherries and chocolate flakes

Apple Pie (Seasonal)

Vanilla ice cream with apples pieces and pie crust

Banana Pudding

Banana pudding ice cream swirled with marshmallow crème and vanilla cookies

Blackberry Cobbler

Blackberry ripples and vanilla wafer cookies surrounded with yummy vanilla ice cream

Black Cherry

Sweet black cherry ice cream loaded with large, black, sweet Bing cherries

Black Raspberry

Black and red raspberry ice cream


Maine wild blueberry ice cream with a sweet blueberry swirl

Butter Pecan

Buttery ice cream with fresh, roasted pecans


A creamy, smooth pure chocolate ice cream

Campfire S’mores

Graham cracker ice cream with chocolate chips and marshmallow swirl

Chocolate Chip

Vanilla ice cream loaded with chocolate chips

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup

Chocolate ice cream swirled with peanut butter and chocolate peanut butter cups


Coconut ice cream loaded with shredded coconut


Rich coffee ice cream


Coffee ice cream with crushed cream-filled chocolate cookies and chocolate coated cookie crumbles

Cookie Dough

Delicious vanilla ice cream loaded with chocolate chip flakes and chunks of cookie dough

Cotton Candy Twist

Bright blue and pink swirled cotton candy flavored ice cream

Chocolate Lovers 

Deep rich chocolate ice cream with chocolate crunchies, fudge swirl and chocolate truffles

Dark Cashew Caramel

Dark chocolate ice cream with a caramel swirl and chocolate covered cashews

Eskimo Kisses 

Coconut ice cream with a chocolate fudge swirl and chocolate truffles

Key Lime Pie 

Rich lime mousse ice cream swirled with lime, whipped cream and graham cracker pieces

Maine Black Bear

Vanilla ice cream laced with a black raspberry swirl and mini black raspberry-filled dark chocolate cups

Majestic Milky Way

Milk chocolate ice cream with a caramel swirl and milky-way pieces

Mint Chocolate Chip

Green mint ice cream loaded with chocolate chips

Mint Cookie Fudge

Mint ice cream with an oreo cookie fudge swirl

Moose Tracks

Vanilla ice cream with a fudge swirl and chocolate peanut butter cups


Vanilla ice cream with delicious cream filled cookie chunks

Party Cake

Cake batter ice cream with blue buttercream frosting swirl and vanilla cake pieces

Peach Orchard

Peach ice cream with peach squares in every bite

Peanut Butter Cold Brew Chip

Mocha Ice cream rippled with peanut butter and chocolate chips

Peanut Butter Pie

Peanut butter ice cream with large peanut butter cups and a graham cracker swirl

Pistachio Almond

Green pistachio nut flavored ice cream with crisp toasted almonds

Play Dough

Bright yellow vanilla with red and blue cookie dough chunks

Pumpkin (Seasonal)

A creamy smooth combo of real pumpkin and pie spices

Rainbow Vanilla

Vanilla ice cream swirled in red, yellow, and blue color

Rocky Road

Chocolate ice cream with marshmallow swirl and almonds


Strawberry ice cream with chunks of real strawberries

Strawberry Cheesecake

Cheesecake ice cream with a strawberry ripple and chunks of traditional cheesecake with a graham cracker swirl

Tennessee Toffee

Toffee ice cream laced with smooth, Jack Daniels whiskey sweet sauce and garnished with broken Heath bars

Toasted Coconut

Coconut ice cream with chocolate covered toasted coconuts flakes


Sweet vanilla ice cream dusted with a pastel rainbow of confetti and stirred together with ultraviolet bubblegum


Rich and creamy vanilla ice cream

Vermont Maple Walnut

Maple ice cream loaded with delicious English walnuts

No Fat | No Sugar Added

NSA Cherry Vanilla

No fat vanilla ice cream with tart red cherries

NSA Vanilla Raspberry 

No fat vanilla ice cream swirled with raspberry ripple

Frozen Yogurt

Black Raspberry Chip

Black raspberry frozen yogurt loaded with chocolate chips

Blueberry Oat Crumble

Vanilla yogurt with a wild blueberry swirl and cinnamon-oatmeal granola

Chocolate Peanut Butter Cup Yogurt

Chocolate frozen yogurt with a peanut swirl and mini peanut butter cups

Sorbet & Sherbet

Blueberry Pomegranate


Sweet blueberry pomegranate sorbet (Dairy Free)

Rainbow Sherbet

Orange, grape, and lime sherbet swirled together

Raspberry Sorbet

Sweet raspberry sorbet (Dairy Free)

Watermelon Sherbet

Refreshing watermelon sherbet

Italian Ice ~NOTE All our Italian ice flavors may change weekly~

Blue Raspberry | Cherry | Lemon | Lime | Mango | Watermelon | Other

Micalizzi's Italian Ice

Wells Hollow Creamery      656 Bridgeport Avenue, Shelton, CT 06484      203.926.0101